Best Key Lime Pie in Key West

History of Key Lime Pie in Key West

Key West, Florida, is a tropical paradise known for many things, but the sleeper hit of the island is the Key lime pie in Key West. Everyone knows Key lime pie is a tangy, sweet dessert, and it’s cherished by both locals and tourists. But this iconic pie holds a special place in Key West’s culinary scene and plays a crucial role in its tourism, drawing food lovers from around the world to savor its delightful flavors. The unique combination of locally grown Key limes, which thrive in the climate of the Florida Keys, and creamy filling makes it a one-of-a-kind treat. Enjoying the best Key lime pie in Key West perfectly captures the essence of Key West’s tropical charm, offering a taste that is both refreshing and indulgent.

Origins of Key Lime Pie

The origins of Key lime pie date back to the late 19th century, when pie recipes using the small tart Key limes available in Key West began to emerge. These early recipes were a product of local innovation, making use of the abundant Key limes. The pie quickly became a local specialty, embodying the resourcefulness of the island’s residents.

How It Became Associated With Key West

Its association with Key West grew as the pie became a staple dessert in local establishments. The combination of those abundant Key limes mentioned previously combined with the invention of condensed milk, crucial for the pie’s creamy filling, made it an immediate hit with the locals. As visitors came and tried the dessert, they recognized it as a truly special treat. As the pie’s fame grew, it became synonymous with the relaxed, sweet life of Key West, enhancing the island’s reputation as a culinary destination.

Hurricane Devastation

Despite its association with Key West, true Key lime trees are rare on the island due to a devastating hurricane in the 1920s. Most Key lime juice today is imported from Mexico and Central America, ensuring the traditional flavor remains authentic despite local agricultural challenges. The hurricane’s impact highlighted the community’s resilience as they continued to cherish and promote their signature dish.

Popularization by Fishermen

Fishermen and sponge divers of the region popularized Key lime pie as a nutritious and easy-to-store treat during long trips, embedding it into the local culture. This practical origin story illustrates how Key lime pie was not only a treat but also a vital part of the maritime community’s diet, as it provided much-needed vitamins and good fuel for the hardworking laborers.

Aunt Sally’s Contribution

The recipe was famously documented by Aunt Sally, a cook for wealthy ship salvager William Curry, further cementing its place in Key West’s culinary tradition. Aunt Sally’s recipe refinement marked the transformation of Key lime pie from a simple concoction to a sophisticated dessert beloved by many.

Official State Pie

In 2006, the Florida State Legislature designated the Key lime pie as the official state pie, acknowledging its deep roots in the culture and history of Key West. This recognition was a proud moment for the locals, celebrating over a century of culinary tradition that started on their tiny island.

Key Lime Pie Facts

World Record

The largest Key lime pie ever made weighed over 1,000 pounds and was crafted in Key West in 2014 as part of the island’s annual Key Lime Festival. This enormous pie showcased the community’s love for this iconic dessert and their dedication to celebrating it, drawing attention from across the globe.

Key Lime Law

In 1965, Florida statesman B.C. Papy Jr. nearly succeeded in having a state legislature passed to prohibit the use of any limes other than Key limes in the pie, a testament to the importance of authenticity in this beloved dessert. This law underscored the cultural significance of using genuine Key limes in the recipe and ensured that the best Key lime pies will always be in Key West.

Haitian Connection

Despite its association with Florida, particularly Key West, most Key limes used in Key lime pies today come from Haiti in addition to the ones imported from Mexico and Central America. This shift occurred after a Category 4 hurricane devastated Florida’s Key lime groves in 1926, leading to the importation of Key limes from other regions to meet demand. Even if sourced externally, the continued use of authentic Key limes reflects the commitment to maintaining the pie’s traditional flavor.

Tahiti Lime Takeover

Post-hurricane, the more durable Tahiti limes, part of the Persian lime family that had been growing in Florida since 1883, replaced the vulnerable Key lime trees. This adaptation ensured the continued production of lime-based recipes despite the agricultural setback.

Dooryard Fruit

In the Florida Keys, Key lime trees are often referred to as “dooryard fruits” because they grow wild in many residents’ backyards, embedding themselves into local life and culture. These trees contribute to the area’s unique culinary landscape, providing fresh limes for various dishes.

State Pie Debate

Although named the official state pie of Florida in 2006, the Key lime pie had to compete with pecan pie, which also had its proponents. This friendly rivalry highlighted the diverse culinary traditions within the state.

Authenticity Matters

Unless you live in Florida, particularly in Key West, or have visited the area, chances are you have not experienced an authentic Key lime pie. Many other states substitute the Key lime with the more readily available Persian lime, which can alter the pie’s distinctive flavor. But don’t let that dishearten you. It only means you get to add a trip to taste the best Key lime pie in Key West to your bucket list.

Publix Legacy

For those familiar with Publix supermarkets, their iconic Key lime pie has been a staple since 1957, continuing to win fans with its distinctive tangy flavor. This popular version has introduced countless people to the unique taste of Key lime pie.

Local Events and Festivals Featuring Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Festival

Held annually from late June to early July, this festival celebrates everything Key lime with various events, including a pie-eating contest, pie-making workshops, and a quirky pie-throwing contest. It’s a must-visit for any Key lime pie enthusiast.

Fantasy Fest

Although primarily known for its elaborate costumes and parades, this October festival often includes Key lime pie-themed events and specials at local eateries. It’s a great opportunity to enjoy the pie in a festive and colorful setting.

Taste of Key West

This April event offers visitors the chance to sample a wide variety of local food and drinks, with many vendors featuring their unique takes on Key lime pie. It’s a food lover’s paradise that highlights the best of Key West’s culinary scene.

Key West Food & Wine Festival

Usually occurring in January, this festival highlights the culinary scene of Key West, and Key lime pie is a staple among the delicious offerings. Wine pairings and gourmet versions of the pie are common features.

Songwriters Festival

In May, the island hosts this music festival where local restaurants and bars serve Key lime pie among other treats to the attending crowd. It’s a perfect blend of music and culinary delights.

Tips for Tourists Seeking the Best Pie Experience

Ask the Locals

Locals can provide the best recommendations for hidden gems and lesser-known spots serving excellent Key lime pie. They know where to find the freshest pies, and their tips can lead you to an unforgettable tasting experience. Local tour guides can also make excellent recommendations.

Try Different Variations

From frozen Key lime pie on a stick to gourmet versions with meringue toppings, Key West offers a variety of takes on this classic dessert. Sampling different variations allows you to discover your personal favorite and appreciate the creativity of local bakers.

Pair With Local Drinks

Enhance your pie experience by pairing it with local drinks like Cuban coffee or a Key lime cocktail. The rich flavors of these beverages complement the tangy sweetness of the pie, creating a delightful taste adventure.

Check for Freshness

Ensure the pie is made with fresh Key lime juice rather than artificial flavoring for an authentic taste. Freshly made pies have a distinctively bright and zesty flavor that truly captures the essence of Key West.

Top-Rated Places To Enjoy Key Lime Pie

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop

Famous for its traditional Key lime pies and unique Key lime pie on a stick dipped in Belgian chocolate. Visitors rave about the charming shop and the fresh, tangy flavor of the pies.

Blue Heaven

Renowned for its towering meringue-topped Key lime pie, this garden-setting restaurant offers a delightful culinary experience. The location is consistently praised for its creamy, authentic Key lime filling.

Key Lime Pie Bakery

Offers a variety of Key lime treats, including classic pies and Key lime cookies. The bakery’s pie is renowned for its rich, smooth texture and perfectly balanced sweetness.

Old Town Bakery

A small bakery with a cozy atmosphere and highly regarded Key lime pie. Their pies are noted for their buttery crust and refreshing citrus punch.

Mattheessen’s

This sweet shop features a delicious Key lime pie with a robust tart flavor and thick graham cracker crust. It is popular among tourists for its generous slices and friendly service.

El Meson de Pepe

Set in a lively Cuban cantina, their Key lime pie is celebrated for its rich, zesty filling and crisp graham cracker crust. Patrons enjoy the culturally rich atmosphere and the delicious blend of Cuban and Key West flavors, making it a must-visit spot for pie lovers.

Attractions in Key West To Complement a Key Lime Pie Experience

Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square

A visit to Key West is not complete without experiencing the renowned Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square. This nightly festival features street performers, local artisans, and food vendors as tourists gather to watch the sunset over the Gulf of Mexico. Enjoy a slice of Key lime pie as you take in the lively atmosphere and breathtaking views.

Key West Historic Seaport

Stroll through the Key West Historic Seaport, a bustling waterfront area full of charm and activity. From boat tours to quaint shops and seafood restaurants, this area is perfect for leisurely exploration. You can find numerous spots to relax and enjoy a slice of Key lime pie while watching the boats go by.

The Southernmost Point Buoy

A famous Key West landmark, the Southernmost Point Buoy marks the southernmost point of the continental United States. Snap a photo here and then head to a nearby café for a refreshing slice of Key lime pie. It’s a quintessential Key West experience that combines sightseeing with delicious local flavors.

Ernest Hemingway Home & Museum

Visit the former residence of the legendary writer Ernest Hemingway. This historic home offers guided tours that delve into Hemingway’s life and works. After exploring the beautiful gardens and learning about Hemingway’s fascinating history, treat yourself to a slice of Key lime pie at a nearby bakery or café.

Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park

For a mix of history and natural beauty, visit Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park. The park features a historic Civil War-era fort, scenic nature trails, and a beautiful beach. Pack a picnic with a slice of Key lime pie and enjoy it by the turquoise waters for a truly relaxing and memorable day.

Key West Butterfly & Nature Conservatory

Immerse yourself in the enchanting world of butterflies at the Key West Butterfly & Nature Conservatory. This tranquil oasis is home to hundreds of butterflies, tropical birds, and lush greenery. After a peaceful visit, find a local eatery to savor a slice of Key lime pie, adding a sweet ending to your serene adventure.

Conclusion

Key lime pie is more than just a dessert; it’s a symbol of Key West’s unique history and culture. From its origins in the 19th century to its status as Florida’s official state pie, Key lime pie has a storied past that is deeply intertwined with the island’s identity. Whether you’re attending a local festival, seeking out the best slice in town, or exploring the charming streets of Key West, indulging in this iconic treat is a must. Embark on your Key lime pie adventure and discover why this tangy, creamy delight holds a special place in the hearts of both locals and visitors alike.

FAQs

What is the history behind Key lime pie in Key West?

The exact history of Key lime pie is shrouded in legend and folklore. There’s no definitive documented account of its creation. However, several popular theories have emerged, including its beginnings in Aunt Sally’s kitchen.

Why is Key West famous for Key lime pie?

Key West is famous for Key lime pie primarily due to the abundance of Key limes in the region. These small tart limes are essential to the pie’s signature flavor. The unique combination of the tart lime juice with the sweetness of condensed milk and the creamy texture of eggs has made Key lime pie a beloved dessert associated with the Florida Keys.

What are some of the best places to try Key lime pie in Key West?

Some popular places to try the best Key lime pie in Key West include El Meson de Pepe, Kermit’s Key Lime Shop, Key Lime Pie Bakery, Key West Key Lime Pie Co, Cafe Sole, and Blue Heaven.